Blog

Resilience and renewal in dark times

17 Nov 2026

 

People around the globe are building their future together. If you’re dismayed at the fraying of democracy, here are sources of inspiration and alliance.

 

David Jacobstein

In nature, certain plants have evolved remarkable adaptations that enable them to withstand the ravages of forest fires. Species like the Ponderosa pine and Douglas fir possess deep root systems that anchor them firmly into the earth, allowing them to access moisture from deeper soil layers, which is crucial during droughts and fires. Their thick bark and high moisture content act as protective barriers against intense heat.

Just as plants with deep roots and tough fibre can endure and recover from wildfires, communities with strong, interconnected systems are better equipped to face and rebound from adversities. Robust social infrastructure provides stability and resources during crises, while strong social bonds can act as the “thick bark” that shields communities from external shocks.

 

Democratic governance – crisis and response

There is a global crisis in democratic governance. According to the International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance (International IDEA), 2023 marked the eighth consecutive year of global democratic backsliding — the longest such period since records began in 1975. Nearly half of the countries assessed experienced declines in areas such as electoral integrity, civil liberties, and parliamentary oversight. Broad dissatisfaction with state performance has enabled elected leaders to erode democratic institutions from within, while autocrats have seized even more power and wealth as global norms falter.

A major contributor to this decline is a shift in how people organize and access information. The erosion of trade union membership, the decline of membership-based associations in favour of funding appeals, and the fragmentation of the media landscape have reshaped civil society. Organizations once rooted in collective action now often prioritize attention-seeking advocacy and high-level policy influence, with a shift from membership to management. This has weakened the communal spaces where people meet and debate issues, building the muscles of democracy and renewing democratic norms. Broad populist movements, while a response in reaction to elite dominance, also tend to focus on exclusion and push for strongman leadership, exacerbated by the echo chambers of social media monetizing attention. Rather than broaden solidarity, populist movements emphasize withdrawal.

In the United States, a growing number of democracy advocates are emphasizing relationships and connection as the foundation of democratic resilience. Political scientist Hahrie Han, for instance, has written persuasively about the power of “everyday democracy”, where people come together to solve shared problems and, in the process, build democratic capacity. She writes:

Imagine neighbors coming together to provide mutual aid during the coronavirus pandemic or a community seeking solutions for a shortage of high-quality childcare. Tranvik describes these efforts as “everyday democracy.” People join these efforts not because they are concerned about democracy per se but instead to solve concrete problems in their lives. In both cases, groups in the community will have distinct interests and goals, leading to important debates about the design and implementation of mutual aid or new childcare facilities. As they work together to hammer out solutions, people learn the hard and soft skills of democracy; they gain appreciation for the negotiations necessary to any effort to solve shared problems; they access a sense of agency often absent with interventionist approaches; and they build relationships and understandings of each other that become a resource for the future. Understanding the value and ubiquity of such efforts reframes the question of reforming democracy from “How do we get people to do a thing?” to “How do we equip people to become the kind of people who do what needs to be done?” Unlike existing paradigms, this approach focuses on the importance of collective experience instead of individual incentives, and prioritizes reforms that build (evidence-based) capabilities for responding to contingency instead of those that yield immediate effects on democratic outcomes.

As existing networks of activists and advocates attempt to reassert democratic norms and values in the US, it is vital that support also be provided to foster ongoing resilience and empower people to hash out issues in collective settings, supporting the long-term local work that is about membership and belonging. Ensuring that there is strategic intent behind such “building” within a mix of blocking harm, bridging divides, and building shared futures requires a clear intent combined with a meaningful structure for action. Such efforts of local problem solving and belonging define ways of working in community philanthropy.

 

International development – paradigm shifting

The global architecture of development assistance is also under strain. Populist scepticism of aid, especially support for “outsiders”, is widespread, and autocratic regimes continue to resist international pressure tied to inclusion, equity, and justice.

Even before recent challenges, the development system was in crisis. It has long operated according to capitalist logics that emphasize efficiency and value for money — as defined by those who provide the funds. Despite rhetorical commitments to local ownership, real power and resources have remained with donors, bilateral agencies, and INGOs. These structures prioritize upward accountability to funders over horizontal accountability to communities.

Efforts to introduce systems thinking and adaptive approaches have gained some traction, but entrenched power dynamics remain. Advocates for embracing systems thinking have long argued that the aid system could not be reformed until its mental models moved from factory floors to complexity and co-evolution. However, funders continue to seek control and predictability, which are often at odds with supporting community-driven solutions. Well intentioned efforts to “find and scale what works” prevented robust innovation in discovering what works well, where, or simply accompanying changemakers and centering outside assistance on adding value to their efforts. The fear of inefficiency and the pressure to deliver measurable outcomes have discouraged experimentation and constrained more relational, trust-based approaches.

 

Community philanthropy

Community philanthropy offers a hopeful alternative. The motivation behind community philanthropy is to engage people with their world in ways that drive change, not to organize philanthropy or channel effective giving. Its purpose is to engage people in shaping their own futures, grounded in relationships, shared assets, and collective decision-making. It embodies values that can help renew democratic practice and reimagine international cooperation on more equitable terms.

Community philanthropy aligns with and supports broader movements for equity, justice, and sustainability in several ways:

  • Democracy and governance → participation, subsidiarity, accountability. The most effective efforts to strengthen democratic governance require broad participation and mutual accountability in ways embodied and reinforced by community philanthropy.
  • Power and autonomy → local control, resistance to top-down systems. Community philanthropy shifts power to local actors, at a moment when reclaiming local autonomy and leadership is central to hopes for democratic renewal.
  • Voice and ownership → narrative sovereignty, community-defined development. Allowing the community to define “the good life” for itself and pursue it in ways suited to their lived experience and beliefs is central to community philanthropy, and reinforces that work of membership and belonging that underpins democratic movement building.

People in societies around the world are showing how forging connections and supporting those in need are both moral goods and sources of democratic resilience. Community philanthropy shares foundational values and methods with several other approaches that aim to rebuild democratic and economic systems:

  • Civic infrastructure work emphasizes the importance of relationships and friction, addressing real issues within the community, and connecting activists, businesspeople, and government leaders to plan collaboratively, while reinforcing their ability to continue these engagements over time. Community philanthropy structures relationship weaving and renews social capital by tapping into existing community assets and capacity to shape conversations around what people want and what tradeoffs are entailed.
  • Community wealth building emphasizes that every person needs to control their own economic future – and have a meaningful stake in the wealth we collectively create. Community philanthropy recognizes and channels existing community assets in ways that align with ensuring investments stay in communities, offering both models and practices.
  • Chris Nkwatsibwe distinguishes financial sustainability from the material freedom to act independently. His exploration of civic wealth and community ownership raises an important question for democratic resilience: whether communities have sufficient control over resources to exercise collective agency, including when their choices challenge those who traditionally provide funding. This idea of material autonomy is a great lens to consider as an approach to building out space within financial relationships.
  • Citizen assemblies help groups of people conduct in-depth analysis of a given issue, a deliberation over different solutions, hearing of the pros and cons, and then, making informed decisions on behalf of their communities. While oriented toward public governance, the processes and approaches are nearly identical to ways many community philanthropy organizations approach deliberation and decision-making.
  • Participatory budgeting is a proven approach to both deepening democracy and engaging people across communities. The openness and accountability, and how this fosters trust among community members, reflect priorities of community philanthropy that are modeled in its function.
  • New understandings of relational state capacity as a core part of how states function are shaping approaches to empowering frontline officials to govern differently, in service of both legitimacy and outcomes. This approach aims to renew focus on the character and quality of relationships between citizens and public servants, by seeing them as humans – individuals and groups of people who can and do exercise agency, and whose understandings and interactions with one another reciprocally shape expectations and ultimately society’s ability to organize to achieve collective goals. This respect for the centrality of relationships is mirrored in the intentional consideration of collective decision-making in community philanthropy and its focus on strengthening connections over time as a central result.
  • Solidarity economy is a global movement to build a just and sustainable economy where we prioritize people and the planet over endless profit and growth. Growing out of social movements in Latin America and the Global South, communities govern themselves through participatory democracy, cooperative and public ownership, and a culture of solidarity and respect for the earth. The culture of mutuality and the emphasis on returning to community over time to grow a better society for the next generation echoes with community philanthropy approaches.
  • Place-based capital as a model and movement aimed at creating local capital systems that are grounded in place, focused on people, and driven by local ownership, decision-making and inclusion. It aims to enable communities to own and manage their assets – like land, businesses, and natural resources – and use them to improve local life. The pooling of resources and collective decision-making, and focus on growing agency within community, reflects core aspects of community philanthropy.

 

Conclusion

Global challenges — from democratic decline to development fatigue — are not merely institutional crises. They reflect the erosion of the relationships, spaces, and narratives that once held collective action together. Yet, across sectors and geographies, people are building anew. Community philanthropy does not stand alone. It is one among many interconnected efforts to renew the fabric of democracy and create more just and inclusive societies. By recognizing and aligning with adjacent movements in democracy, economic justice, and governance, we can weave a stronger, more resilient system.

Now is the time to link arms, share tools, and stand in solidarity. The roots are already deep. The bark is already thick. What remains is to recognize the forest for what it is: alive, interconnected, and ready to regenerate.

 

By: David Jacobstein, Johns Hopkins SAIS and Council, Systems Practice Community. David can be reached on LinkedIn or at davidjacobstein311@gmail.com. Read other pieces from David: 

guest
0 Comments
oldest
newest